Sheets was found dead at a home in Lake Havasu City, Ariz., on April 22, police told E! News in a statement. 

Officers responded to a report of a deceased individual around 2 a.m. and he was pronounced dead on the scene. Police said he appeared to have died by suicide, though the case remains under investigation.

Following his passing, Laura remembered Sheets as a “truly, truly was a wonderful, loving person who believed in God.”

In addition to his faith and his bargain hunting business, Sheets enjoyed music and spending time with his family, including partner Kimber Naisbitt Pino.

“Kimber is the love of my life, and is my biggest supporter of this unique business that I’m in,” he said in his Fox Business bio. “I have two kids, Kimber has two kids, and between us we have four beautiful grandchildren that I love being around.”