The 58-year-old—mom to daughters Sea, 28, and Teddy, 26, with ex Gilles Bensimon—confessed she was feeling quite torn after being charmed by Nick, who she met on the dating app Raya, and Juan, who she met during her horse-riding date with Nick.

“Literally, I walk up and I see Juan and I go, ‘Holy sugar!'” Kelly recounted. “Then Nick rolls up and he’s like, ‘Howdy,’ and I was like, ‘This guy is so cute.'”

And it’s easy to see why the former model had trouble choosing between the two men. While Nick was “so hot” and “just the sweetest, kindest guy,” according to Kelly, Juan was like “a Telenovela star.”

Of course, only time will tell if Kelly has met her Mr. Right. In the meantime, the former NYC housewife is still perusing the dating apps for potential suitors.

And, boy, does she have an unexpected go-to opening line with the guys.