A convicted killer who raped and murdered a heavily pregnant teacher before brutally killing her husband has been executed – despite maintaining his innocence in his chilling final words.
Thomas Overton, 71, was pronounced dead at 6.19pm on Thursday, November 19, at Florida State Prison in Raiford, Florida, following a lethal injection.
The execution brought an end to a decades-long saga that began with the horrific murders of much-loved teacher Susan Michelle ‘Missy’ MacIvor, 29, and her husband Michael, 30, in 1991.
Missy was eight months pregnant when Overton broke into the couple’s home, raped and strangled her, and attacked her husband in a savage assault that also claimed the life of their unborn child.
But even as he faced his final moments, Overton refused to accept responsibility for the killings. According to the Associated Press, his lingering words were: ‘I never killed anyone.’
His execution went ahead after the US Supreme Court rejected his request for a stay on Thursday, clearing the way for Florida officials to carry out the death sentence.
Overton was put to death using the state’s three-drug lethal injection procedure.
The first drug administered was etomidate, a sedative intended to render him unconscious. This was followed by rocuronium bromide, a neuromuscular blocking agent that causes paralysis of voluntary muscles.

Florida has executed Thomas Overton, 71, by lethal injection today, Nov. 19, at Florida State Prison in Raiford, for the 1991 rape and murder of pregnant Monroe County teacher Susan Michelle “Missy” MacIvor, 29, and the murder of her husband, Michael MacIvor, 30
Overton, then 35, met Missy MacIvor in 1991 at a gas station where he worked. Two inmates incarcerated with Overton testified that he admitted to breaking into the MacIvor home to rape Missy MacIvor, who was eight months pregnant
The US Supreme Court denied Overton’s request for a stay of execution Nov. 19. Overton awoke at 5 am, remained compliant, received no visitors and did not meet with a spiritual advisor
The final drug was potassium acetate, which disrupts the heart’s electrical activity, resulting in cardiac arrest and death.
According to Florida Department of Corrections spokesman Jordan Kirkland, the condemned inmate woke at around 5am and remained compliant throughout the day.
He received no visitors and did not meet with a spiritual adviser before being taken to the death chamber.
Court records detail how Overton, then 35, met Missy while working at a gas station before later breaking into the couple’s home.
Two inmates who were subsequently incarcerated alongside Overton testified that he had confessed to entering the property with the intention of raping the pregnant teacher.
Once inside, he encountered Michael and struck him with a pipe, beating him unconscious.
Overton then raped and strangled the pregnant teacher before turning his attention back to her husband.
Michael was kicked and strangled during the attack, which left both adults dead. Their unborn baby also died.
James MacIvor, brother of Michael MacIvor (pictured) spoke at a news conference held shortly after the execution of Thomas Mitchell Overton across the street from Florida State Prison
Florida Department of Corrections spokesperson Jordan Kirkland also weighed in at the news conference

Members of Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty and other campaign groups planned to gather near Florida State Prison to demonstrate against the execution. Further vigils were organized at churches in St Augustine and St Johns, while Death Penalty Action hosted a virtual gathering
The brutal killings devastated those who knew the couple and became the subject of a lengthy criminal investigation and subsequent prosecution.
Overton was ultimately convicted and sentenced to death for the crimes.
His execution marks a significant milestone for Florida, which has now carried out 20 executions in 2026 – breaking the previous state record of 19, set in 2025.
The record-breaking pace has made Florida responsible for more executions this year than the rest of the United States combined.
Governor Ron DeSantis has defended the state’s use of capital punishment, arguing that carrying out death sentences provides justice for victims and their families, some of whom have waited decades for executions.
And two further executions are already scheduled in Florida before the end of the year.
Ricardo Gonzalez, convicted of murdering North Miami police officer Steven Bauer during a 1992 bank robbery, is scheduled to die on December 1.
Willie Seth Crain Jr, who was convicted of murdering seven-year-old Amanda Brown in 1998, is scheduled to be executed on December 19.
Despite the mounting number of executions, Florida’s record remains below the modern national high. Texas executed 40 prisoners in 2000.
Overton’s death also prompted renewed protests from opponents of capital punishment.
Members of Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty and other campaign groups planned to gather near Florida State Prison to demonstrate against the execution.
Further vigils were organized at churches in St Augustine and St Johns, while Death Penalty Action hosted a virtual gathering.
The protests came as supporters of capital punishment pointed to the lengthy wait for justice in cases involving victims and their families.