So, Nikki decided to take a different approach when teasing the 51-year-old—who has been in a relationship with model Vittoria Ceretti, 27, since 2023.

“Me and my writing team found a Teen Beat article from 1991,” Nikki recalled. “I was like, ‘Leo, we don’t know anything about you. The only thing we know about you is from a Teen Beat article in 1991, where you told us your favorite food is pasta, pasta, and more pasta.'”

“He sent me three baskets of pasta as a thank you,” Nikki added. “He sent me pasta. So funny. So good. Part of me was like, ‘Does Leo want to smash?’ Like, I was like, ‘All right.’ Then I was like, ‘The type of girl he goes for, he wouldn’t send pasta to.’ It was a dry pasta.”