The resemblance between Alyson Hannigan and her daughter Keeva is legend—wait for it—dary.

Fans had to do a double take when the How I Met Your Mother actress snapped a selfie with the 14-year-old during a recent visit to a Jellycat pop-up in Los Angeles.

As seen in a Sept. 26 Instagram post, Hannigan and her mini me looked almost identical with their matching red hair, which they styled with similar middle parts.

“That’s your exact twin,” one commenter wrote, while another quipped, “I only see two Alysons.”

A third fan even joked that Hannigan’s husband Alexis Denisof‘s genes “didn’t stand a chance,” with many others joking that it was basically a “copy & paste” job.

It’s a sentiment familiar to Hannigan, who shares Keeva and 17-year-old daughter Satyana with her former Buffy the Vampire Slayer costar. In fact, the 52-year-old said her teen girls now can now see just how much they actually look alike by revisiting their parents’ show.