Politics and Economics Editor, Australia

Published: | Updated:
Labor is right to close a super loophole Treasury expects will cost taxpayers $480 million over the next decade.
But can it please stop making villains out of the retirees who have used it up until now?
The loophole allows people to use their super to buy a product that will pay them an income for life, sometimes years before they retire.
When Centrelink later works out how much Age Pension they qualify for, it uses an assumed rate of return to value the investment.
If the fund has earned more, some of that growth effectively disappears from the assets test. The earlier someone buys in, the more time there is for that gap to grow.
Which means two people can arrive at retirement with the same savings, yet one can qualify for a bigger pension.
Imagine two retired nurses who worked the same shifts, earned the same money and put away the same amount for their retirement.
One bought into a lifetime income product years ago. The other waited until she finished work.
Why should the date they signed the paperwork entitle one of them to more taxpayer support every fortnight?
On that question, I’m with Labor.
Labor is right to close a super loophole Treasury expects will cost taxpayers $480 million over the next decade. But that doesn’t mean the retirees who used it are villains
I’d be equally interested to hear what either nurse did wrong. One might reasonably ask why her colleague gets a bigger pension.
The other might reasonably reply that she took financial advice and followed the rules. I reckon they both have a point.
So what does the change mean for you? If you already have money in one of these products, Labor says your existing balance will keep its current treatment.
That’s fair enough. People chose when they can afford to finish work on the strength of the rules Canberra has in place.
A 70-year-old former nurse can hardly ring the hospital and ask for her Tuesday shifts back because the Treasurer has since revised the rules.
Changes that are retrospective are especially bad for retirees, but that’s not happening here.
For new investors, the standard 40 per cent discount under the assets test will still apply to eligible lifetime income products.
What Labor wants to remove is the extra advantage that arises when the formula understates how much the investment has grown.
That can affect how much pension Centrelink puts in your bank account each fortnight.
Your super savings are still yours, however.
Which brings us to the part of this debate that ought to make Jim Chalmers a little less pleased with himself.
The word ‘loophole’ is doing an awful lot of political work and may not necessarily describe the situation for many recipients. Above is a stock image
The word ‘loophole’ does an awful lot of political work. It invites you to picture a wealthy retiree chuckling over lunch about the lurk his accountant found him.
The retired nurse who went along to a super seminar at work and acted on what she learnt makes a rather less convenient target.
But both of the above have taken advantage of the rules as written up until now. Neither deserves to be demonised.
Chalmers has a perfectly good case for changing the rules, and he’s right not to make the change retrospective.
He should give the class warfare a rest on this one. It’s cheap politics.
Meanwhile, Labor is also moving to stop unlicensed telemarketers from cold calling Australians about their super.
Given that those being banned are unlicensed, it’s hard to argue with the change! Far better to only hear from people qualified to hand over the advice they are spruiking.
After the Shield and First Guardian collapses – total cost over a billion dollars – dodgy sales tactics deserve far more scrutiny than they’ve had up until now.