A soundbar is by far the most popular upgrade when a new TV’s speakers turn out to be a let-down, and it’s not hard to see why. You get one box, one cable, and a significant improvement in dialogue clarity, which is exactly why we’ve previously made the case for choosing a soundbar over traditional speakers.
When the regret does come, though, it usually comes from the same place, namely the gap between what the box claims and what a single bar of speakers under your TV can actually achieve. If you’re in the market for one (or you’re just wondering why yours doesn’t sound as good as it did in the store), these are the compromises I’d want to know about before handing over any money.
Surround sound is mostly a clever illusion
But there’s only so much one box can do
Most soundbars lean heavily on surround sound in their marketing, and plenty now promise Dolby Atmos too, even though most are single cabinets sitting in front of you. To create the sense of extra speakers, they use psychoacoustic processing (timing and frequency tricks that convince your brain a sound is coming from somewhere else), and pricier models add side and upward-firing drivers to bounce audio off your walls and ceiling. Dolby describes its height virtualization as a way of recreating overhead effects without actual overhead speakers, which is essentially what you’re paying for.
In a plain, box-shaped room with a flat ceiling, the effect can be genuinely convincing. Put the same bar in an open-plan space, under a vaulted ceiling, or anywhere heavy curtains soak up the reflections, and it tends to collapse back into a wide stereo image. If you went in expecting helicopters to fly overhead, that’s usually the point where reality sets in.
Your TV’s HDMI port can actually downgrade the sound
And it rarely tells you it’s doing it
A Dolby Atmos logo on the soundbar doesn’t guarantee your TV can send it everything it can handle. Plenty of older or budget TVs only have HDMI ARC rather than eARC, and the difference is more than just a letter.
I’ve covered this in more detail in a piece on why your soundbar probably can’t decode half of what your TV is sending it, but here’s the short version.
|
Audio bandwidth |
Around 1Mbps |
Around 37Mbps |
|---|---|---|
|
Streamed Dolby Atmos (Dolby Digital Plus) |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Lossless Dolby Atmos (Dolby TrueHD) |
No |
Yes |
|
DTS-HD Master Audio |
No |
Yes |
|
Multichannel PCM (5.1/7.1) |
No, stereo only |
Yes |
|
Automatic lip-sync correction |
Optional |
Mandatory |
Streaming apps send Atmos in compressed Dolby Digital Plus, which ARC handles perfectly well, so if you’re mostly watching Netflix or Disney+, you’re unlikely to notice. If you’ve got a collection of 4K Blu-rays, though, an ARC-only TV means you’re effectively paying for lossless audio your soundbar will never receive.
The handshake with your TV isn’t always reliable
So expect the odd standoff between remotes
A big part of the soundbar’s appeal is that it disappears into your setup, turning on with the TV and (in theory, at least) answering to the same remote via HDMI-CEC, the control protocol that lets HDMI devices talk to each other. When it works, it’s seamless, but when it doesn’t, you might find the soundbar stays asleep, the TV reverts to its own speakers, or the volume buttons only work when they feel like it. Those issues can also appear or vanish with firmware updates on either device.
Each brand has its own name for CEC (Anynet+ on Samsung, SimpLink on LG and Bravia Sync on Sony), so that doesn’t really help when you’re trying to get to the bottom of an issue. Even Sonos, which is generally quite good at setup, can have a few common soundbar issues related to power and remote response. Lip sync can also drift, particularly over basic ARC, where the auto-correction is optional rather than mandatory.
A software update can change what you paid for
Or, in the worst cases, break it entirely
Modern soundbars are, in effect, small computers, so the product you buy may not be quite the one you own a year later. Sonos users found this out in May 2024, when its rebuilt app arrived with key features missing and bugs everywhere. The company estimated the fix at $20 million to $30 million, and CEO Patrick Spence stepped down in January 2025.
Samsung had a similar moment in March 2025 with firmware version 1020.7, which left some HW-Q990D soundbars (the flagship at the time) and several other 2024 models entirely unresponsive. Samsung offered free repairs in all cases, regardless of warranty, though the fix was physical rather than another update.
Neither case is the norm, of course, and plenty of updates add features rather than take them away. But a pair of passive speakers and an amp won’t rely on an app team having a good week, so if you’re planning to keep your setup for the long haul, I’d factor that in.
Upgrading usually means replacing the whole thing
Because most systems only expand within one brand
A traditional home theater is built up piece by piece. You can swap the center speaker, upgrade the subwoofer, or replace the AV receiver, and the rest of the system carries on. Soundbars are much less flexible here, since most pair wirelessly only with rear speakers and subwoofers from the same manufacturer (and sometimes only from the same product line), so a Sonos bar generally wants Sonos surrounds, and a Samsung bar wants Samsung ones.
That also means everything ages together. If HDMI standards move on or one component fails, the whole unit usually goes with it. If you’d like to build up to a full surround system gradually, I’d read up on soundbar vs. surround sound before committing to an ecosystem you may well outgrow.
Music rarely sounds as good as movies and TV do
Since the left and right speakers sit so close together
Soundbars are built mainly for film and TV, so most prioritize dialogue clarity and bass. That works well for their main job, but music is where they tend to fall short. The left and right drivers sit much closer together than a pair of speakers either side of the screen, so the stereo image is narrower, and the movie modes many bars default to can smear a mix that was never meant for surround sound.
If music matters as much as movies, check out a pair of powered bookshelf speakers with HDMI ARC. You lose virtual surround but gain proper stereo separation, and some models will even turn on and off with your TV.
Where you put it can undo a lot of good work
Especially if it ends up tucked inside a TV cabinet
Upward-firing drivers need a clear path to a flat ceiling, and side-firing ones need nearby walls, so a bar tucked into a shelf or closed cabinet loses much of its effect. On a low TV stand, a taller soundbar can also cover the bottom of the screen or block the TV’s IR sensor, and neither will be apparent in a product photo.
Before you buy, I’d measure the gap between your stand and the bottom of the screen and check where your TV’s IR receiver sits. Some of the best free soundbar upgrades come down to positioning, too, so if you already own one, it’s worth a second look.
Why most people still won’t regret buying one
Yet knowing the trade-offs makes it easier to choose well
None of this means soundbars are a bad idea. For most people, the realistic alternative is the TV’s own speakers rather than a 7.1 system with a receiver, and almost any decent soundbar will win on dialogue. Dedicated speech modes have improved, too, with our editor finding the Bose Lifestyle Ultra’s SpeechClarity mode good enough to turn off subtitles.
If you’re renting, living somewhere small, or simply don’t want cables everywhere, the convenience is genuine, and that’s a solid reason to buy one.
If you mainly want clearer dialogue and a clean setup, a soundbar is still the simplest upgrade going. If you’re after real surround, care a lot about music, or want something you can build on over time, a pair of speakers or a basic receiver-based system will likely serve you better. And if you’re buying at the lower end, knowing how to avoid getting ripped off by a cheap soundbar will probably save you most of the regret on this list.
