A good transformation can win awards. A messy one can launch a thousand think pieces. Here are 19 actors who disappeared into a role so hard that the backlash became more viral than the film:
1.
Bradley Cooper’s Maestro transformation became controversial the second the trailer dropped. Viewers immediately called out the prosthetic nose Cooper wore to play the Jewish American composer and conductor, Leonard Bernstein. Critics argued the choice leaned into antisemitic stereotypes, especially because Cooper is not Jewish. The movie’s awards-season conversation subsequently shifted from his performance to the question of whether the prosthetic was even necessary.
Bernstein’s children publicly defended the prosthetic by saying, “It’s just such an annoying distraction […] The people who were waiting to get mad about something were just waiting to pounce.”
2.
Robert Downey Jr.’s Tropic Thunder role is still one of the most debated actor transformations, as he plays a white method actor who surgically darkens his skin to portray a Black soldier. Defenders argue the joke is about clueless Hollywood actors, while critics say blackface is blackface.
During an episode of The Joe Rogan Experience podcast, RDJ defends his choice by stating, “90% of my Black friends were like, ‘Dude, that was great.’ I can’t disagree with [the other 10%], but I know where my heart lies.”
3.
Ariana Grande’s Wicked transformation has been widely debated, with people claiming that Glinda has fully taken over her speaking and singing voice, wardrobe, skin color, and overall mannerisms. Every recent clip of Grande has turned into a debate in the comments about whether “Glinda has finally released her.”
At this point, anything Grande does is accused of being “stuck in character.” One TikTok user even wrote, “Sad. Ariana is stuck in character. Not the same person.”
4.
Austin Butler’s Elvis transformation was widely clowned because the Elvis voice seemed to stick around. After three years of intense “method” acting, he kept speaking with a noticeable Elvis-like accent during awards season, prompting people to wonder whether he was still stuck in character all these years later…
During an appearance on The Late Show With Stephen Colbert, Butler said he “had a dialect coach just to help me not sound like Elvis.” He further admitted that he struggled to rediscover himself after filming wrapped on Baz Luhrmann’s Elvis.
5.
Brendan Fraser’s comeback role in The Whale sparked major backlash for wearing a fat suit and prosthetics to play Charlie, a 600-pound man. While his performance was praised by some and even won an Oscar, critics argued that the movie turned fatness into tragedy and spectacle, raising the question of why the role didn’t just go to a fat actor.
In response to the backlash, Fraser says, “I’m not a small man. And I don’t know what the metric is to qualify to play the role. I only know that I had to give as honest a performance as I can.”
6.
Before Barbie even came out, images of Ryan Gosling as Ken were trending…he was getting dragged by people who thought he was too old, not “Ken” enough, or just a bad casting choice. The bleach-blonde hair and spray-tanned look made the discourse even louder — until the movie came out, finally allowing people to understand the vision.
An X user questioned Gosling’s casting by saying, “Ryan and Margot, especially Ryan, look old as hell to me for this film. 46-year-old Ken doll […] Why would a youthful Barbie need to be casted old? I never envisioned my Barbies looking old as sh*t.”
7.
Back to Black faced immense backlash, with Amy Winehouse fans criticizing the actress’s look, voice, and the biopic’s overall existence. Especially since Amy’s life, addiction, and death had already been so publicly exploited, many people felt uncomfortable watching Hollywood monetize her pain into a dramatized movie.
A Reddit user criticized the film by writing, “I really, really wanted the new Amy Winehouse movie to not be an insulting Lifetime original, yet here we are. Complete waste of $30.”
8.
Sydney Sweeney’s portrayal of Cassie in Euphoria has sparked major online debate, with people saying the character’s behavior and politics mirror Sweeney’s real-life public image. Especially after years of controversy with her mom’s “Make Sixty Great Again” party, her controversial American Eagle “great jeans/genes” ad, and the ongoing conversation that she gives off a male-centered energy. As Cassie’s styling and words get more “conservative-coded,” critics feel that Sweeney is just “playing herself.”
An X user wrote, “Cassie confirming she’s a Republican. Sydney Sweeney must have loved reading that.”
9.
Disney’s live-action Snow White became controversial, in part, for how it handled the Seven Dwarfs. After Peter Dinklage criticized remaking a story built on dwarf stereotypes, Disney changed its approach and recast the Seven Dwarfs to be CGI-animated characters. Soon after, other actors with dwarfism publicly called out Dinklage and Disney for taking away already limited roles instead of improving them.
In a Club Shay Shay interview, Brad Williams, an actor and comedian with dwarfism, expressed his frustration by saying, “I would have played a dwarf in the live-action Snow White movie, but then they took out the dwarves. Thanks, Dinklage. […] Do you know that you took work away from me and my 6-year-old dwarf daughter.”
10.
Lady Gaga’s House of Gucci transformation got roasted the more she talked about staying in character as Patrizia Reggiani for months and using the accent off-camera. The controversy around the “Italian” accent especially grew, with viewers debating whether she sounded Italian, Russian, campy, or all three…
An X user commented, “I mean, with that accent, she would have killed in Anora, but not in this one. That’s a Russian accent, not Italian.”
11.
Ana de Armas and Blonde faced boycotts the second the trailer was released, with people clowning her Marilyn Monroe voice and debating her accent. The controversy only grew after the movie’s release, when the movie was further criticized as exploitative and even anti-abortion propaganda due to a CGI fetus scene depicting Marilyn’s rumored abortions.
A Reddit user commented, “Not only does it feature two abortions and a miscarriage, but almost all the scenes that surround it are about that as well.”
12.
Emilia Pérez faced backlash for many reasons, but Selena Gomez’s criticism specifically focused on her Spanish-language performance. Viewers criticized her accent and delivery, especially after Mexican actor Eugenio Derbez called her performance “indefensible.” But the discourse quickly grew beyond Selena, with many viewers criticizing the French-made movie for reducing Mexico to stereotypes. Karla Sofía Gascón’s resurfaced offensive tweets made its awards-season success feel even messier.
Gomez commented on a post of Derbez criticizing her, “I understand where you are coming from. I’m sorry I did the best I could with the time I was given.”
13.
It’s no surprise that Sebastian Stan’s portrayal of a young Donald Trump in The Apprentice was controversial, because we all know that anything Trump is always a heated topic of conversation. Although the scrutiny wasn’t just about whether he looked or sounded right, it was more about concerns around whether the movie would humanize Trump, mock him, or turn him into a biopic antihero.
I think the film successfully struck a nerve…: “A FAKE and CLASSLESS Movie written about me, called, ‘The Apprentice’ (Do they even have the right to use that name without approval?), will hopefully ‘bomb,'” Trump wrote on Truth Social. “It’s a cheap, defamatory, and politically disgusting hatchet job, put out right before the 2024 Presidential Election, to try and hurt the Greatest Political Movement in the History of our Country, ‘MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN!'”
14.
Jared Leto’s House of Gucci transformation as Paolo Gucci was so extreme that people joked he looked like he wandered in from another movie. Between the bald cap, prosthetics, accent, and very big acting choices, critics felt the performance to be less like Gucci and more like an Italian caricature.
A Reddit user expressed their thoughts by writing, “For better or for worse, Leto’s performance is quite a memorable and stand-out one. He’s probably not even good in it (arguably terrible), but I was definitely entertained to the point where I’m not even thaaat angry he’s beating out other (much better) contenders despite having little interest in Leto as an actor otherwise.”
15.
Lily James’s Pamela Anderson transformation in Pam & Tommy was visually shocking, but the real backlash came from Pamela herself, who did not approve of the series being made. Since the show dramatized her stolen private tape and her turbulent relationship with Tommy Lee, critics felt that the actors involved exploited and glamorized one of the worst periods of her life without her permission.
Anderson reveals that James sent her a handwritten letter “to ask if they could speak,” which she promptly ignored. The Baywatch star reiterated, “It was already hurtful enough the first time. […] ‘Really? People are still capitalizing off that thing?'”
16.
Michael Jackson has always been a widely discussed figure, so a biopic (Michael) made with heavy involvement from his family was bound to raise questions. MJ’s nephew, Jaafar Jackson, clearly got the resemblance and dancing down for the main role. But critics were more concerned about whether the movie would address the other parts of Michael’s life — including his allegations, difficult childhood, and changing appearance — making them wonder whether it would be a transparent biopic or a sanitized tribute.
An X user wrote, “I need the movie to talk about his nose job because that nose was done done.”
17.
Emma Stone’s Poor Things performance sparked backlash as her character has the body of an adult woman but the developing mind of a child. While many praised the role as bold and feminist, others were uncomfortable with the movie’s sexual scenes and questioned whether its version of empowerment crossed into exploitation.
Some Reddit users wrote, “There is literally a line in the film where Mark Ruffalo says, ‘What happened, Bella? You’re losing your charming way of speaking,’ when Bella starts to mature. If that isn’t a clear enough commentary on how men prey on and prefer younger, naive women, I don’t know what is.” While defenders wrote back, “It’s supposed to be uncomfortable, that’s the entire point.”
18.
Eddie Redmayne’s role in The Danish Girl was criticized because he is a cisgender man playing Lili Elbe, one of the first known people to undergo gender-affirming surgery. The casting became part of a larger conversation about Hollywood rewarding cis actors for playing trans characters while trans actors already struggle to get roles.
In an interview, Redmayne admits, “No, I wouldn’t take it on now. I made that film with the best intentions, but I think it was a mistake,” and he acknowledges there had been “years of cisgender success on the back of trans stories.”
Critics called out, “Guys, there’s literally people on TikTok making thirst traps on Jeffrey Dahmer. It’s terrible.”
What are some other actor transformations that completely missed the mark? Share your thoughts in the comments or fill out the anonymous form below — your response could be featured in an upcoming BuzzFeed Community post!
