Not picking up on the clue about Alexi’s U.S. Men’s National Team number, Robin Thicke ultimately guessed he was Tom Brady, Jenny picked fellow Patriots alum Julian Edelman, Ken Jeong argued it was Travis Kelce and Rita landed on Jason Sudeikis. So, the judges were totally shocked when the athlete finally revealed himself. Although, as Alexi pointed out, there was a soccer ball on his head the entire time.

“By the way,” the Olympian joked during his send-off, “I’m so sorry I’m not Tom Brady.”

And while he stumped the judges, Alexi had an incredible time flexing a different muscle on the show.

“I grew up playing in garage bands and then singing in chamber singers,” he shared. “And so while I was doing sports, music was a huge part of my life. And this is so much more than music, by the way. This is so much more than singing.”

And how did being on The Masked Singer compare to playing in the World Cup?

“Well, I gotta tell you, I think that I sweat more in this than I ever sweated on the soccer [field],” he laughed. “I got sweat in places, ladies and gentlemen, that you do not wanna see.”

Keep reading to see all the celebs who have been revealed so far this season on The Masked Singer.

The Masked Singers airs Wednesdays at 8 p.m. on Fox.