Tiff’s Treats introduced The Cookie Pie as a six-inch, deep-dish cookie made to be eaten with a spoon and shared in four varieties: Chocolate Chip, Double Chocolate Chip, Snickerdoodle, and Birthday Confetti.

While some people may pass on a full dessert in favor of saving money or calories, the craving for a little indulgence still lingers. Shareable sweets like cookie pies strike the perfect balance, offering a satisfying treat that’s easy to split and gentle on the wallet—and Tiff’s Treats’ shareable Cookie Pie is just $10.

Customers can uplevel the enjoyment of their Cookie Pie by ordering it à la mode with a pint of ice cream, or buttercream Frost ’ems for spreading or dipping.