Over on Reddit, people went even harder explaining why they wouldn’t want to see Andy’s “whiny” ex-boyfriend return to Devil Wears Prada ever again.

“C’mon dude, in what world is Andy’s whiny boyfriend from Devil Wears Prada getting his own spinoff? Boy bye,” one Reddit user said. Another echoed, “We don’t need a whiny boyfriend thanks.”

“I mean yeah, his character is the worst part of the movie. It’s not entirely his fault, but the whiny boyfriend who keeps putting down his girlfriend’s career isn’t why the movie is getting a sequel,” another person wrote.

“Andy’s friends and BF were boring and unnecessary. They brought nothing. It was to show the effects of her hard-work career on her life, but it was still too much,” someone else wrote. Another added, “He and her other friends were the worst.”

“ain’t no one come to see you, Otis!” another redditor joked. “He hated Andie’s job, so…why would he be back? He gave her so much grief instead of trying to see she was getting swept away.”

And this person said, “I think his arc was complete, I don’t know what else he would bring to the sequel.”