For May, Raaka Chocolate’s First Nibs Two Bar Subscription treats members to two spicy chocolate bars: Guajillo Chile Pepper and Chipotle Chile Pepper. Both made with cacao sourced from Kokoa Kamili, Tanzania, these micro-batch dark chocolate bars with a kick offer similar yet different spicy experiences. The Guajillo chile pepper offers a mild to moderate heat with a sweet, tangy flavor, and the Chipotle chile—made from smoked, dried jalapeños—delivers a slightly hotter, smokier kick.

During the roasting process, the natural fruity flavor disappears from the chocolate but Raaka Chocolate makes its transparently traded single-origin dark chocolate without roasting so that it can be appreciated. As with all creations from the brand, these certified organic chocolate bars are free from gluten, dairy and soy.