There are few positions as vulnerable as that of a patient undergoing surgery.
The anxiety over the procedure. The fear of infections. The concerns about recovery time. How heightened these emotions will be for patients booked in at the Aberdeen Royal Infirmary.
Whistleblower Dr Mohammed Habib paints a picture of clinical catastrophe which cost the lives of 19 people who underwent hepatobiliary (liver, gallbladder, and bile duct) surgery.
His dramatic intervention last week, in which he released internal documents to support his claims, has forced the Scottish Government’s hand.
Over the weekend Health Secretary Angela Constance announced ‘an urgent and fully independent review’ into what went wrong. She said: ‘Patient safety and high-quality care must always be the first concern of all those who work in, and with, the NHS.’
Must be, ought to be, but is it always?
Dr Habib’s evidence casts that into doubt, and doubt will hang over NHS Grampian like a pall until the review reports and its recommendations are seen to be put in place.
To some extent, health service bosses can rely on that deference to the NHS inculcated in Britons from their earliest years. Don’t cause a fuss. Those poor nurses are run off their feet. We’re lucky it’s not like America; if you can’t pay there, they just leave you to die.

Health Secretary Angela Constance has announced an ‘urgent’ review
This forelock-tugging fealty to a mediocre healthcare bureaucracy, like a feudal peasant to the nobleman who tosses him scraps every now and then, can only last through so many scandals before the peasants turn on the lanyarded gentry.
But no amount of docility towards the NHS can convince patients to overlook 19 needless deaths – deaths that might very well have been them or someone they love. That might yet be. Trust is forsaken in seconds but rebuilt in years.
NHS Grampian has questions to answer but it is not the only one.
Dr Habib said he wrote to the government four times, with three of the letters sent to the First Minister personally, to raise the alarm but was not satisfied with any of the responses.
Nor will the public be satisfied because, despite these repeated warnings, John Swinney and his ministers said nothing. Nineteen out of 31 deaths during liver, gallbladder and bile duct operations were avoidable, according to a 2022 NHS Grampian report. Ministers knew. And they chose to withhold this information from patients.
Governments are seldom enthusiastic about transparency but few are quite as allergic as this one. Ministers spent years dodging and downplaying warnings about infection control at the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital in Glasgow. Parliamentary questions and damning headlines were met with stonewalling, talking points, and the national anthem of devolved Scotland: ‘Things are worse in Wales.’
It took the courage and determination of two women, Kimberly Darroch and Louise Slorance, whose lives were shattered by that hospital but who spoke up and kept speaking up until they were heard.
Kimberly lost her daughter, Milly Main, who was just ten. Milly, who was diagnosed with leukaemia, had stem-cell therapy at the Queen Elizabeth in 2017, but while the transplant worked she contracted fatal stenotrophomonas maltophilia via medical tubing.
Louise’s husband Andrew, a 49-year-old Scottish Government staffer, also received a stem-cell transplant to treat blood cancer at the Queen Elizabeth. Six weeks later, in December 2020, he died from a pneumonia linked to Covid.
His wife described how, despite Andrew having a compromised immune system, he was moved to a Covid ward. Evidence of the mould aspergillus was also found in his system.
The deaths of Milly and Andrew are now being reviewed by the Crown Office as possible corporate homicide cases, alongside those of Gail Armstrong, 73, Molly Cuddihy, 23, Tony Dynes, 63, and two children, aged three and ten, who remain anonymous.
In time, the Crown Office might also have to review some of the 19 deaths at the Aberdeen Royal Infirmary.
The prosecutorial fact-finding process can be long and arduous – in the interests of justice, it ought to be – and it will be for the law officers to decide whether there are cases to answer. Prosecutions with limited chance of success cannot be launched as a remedy to public anger or patient trepidation.
Whistleblower Dr Mohammed Habib (right) with lawyer Aamer Anwar
But it is also the case that where hospitals kill their patients, whether through clinical error or poor infection control, one of the barriers to addressing the problem is a lack of corporate homicide prosecutions.
The Royal College of Emergency Medicine estimates Scotland saw 818 excess deaths linked to A&E waits of longer than 12 hours in 2024. If there were more than 800 deaths in a single year among Scots waiting for emergency responses from the police or fire brigades, it would be the subject of public inquiries.
Reducing avoidable deaths in hospitals is not only a matter of better investment or organisation. Until there are meaningful deterrents – up to and including routine corporate homicide prosecutions – patients will continue to lose their lives, or have their lives shortened, needlessly.
Clinicians and support staff work within parameters set by hospitals, hospitals within parameters set by health boards, and health boards within parameters set by ministers. Corporate homicide investigations that limit themselves to the actions of a particular hospital or health board risk allowing the real culprits to go scot-free.
Where fatalities can be traced directly to a ministerial directive – for example, instructing the discharge of certain patients to high-risk settings during a pandemic – that directive should be the subject of a criminal investigation.
Similarly, where ministers fail to act upon warnings, whether from a health board or a whistleblower, or where they withhold from patients information that is in the public interest, they should be liable to prosecution.
And the toothless gesture-legislation which introduced ‘legally binding’ waiting times targets – the work of Nicola Sturgeon, naturally – should be given teeth in the form of fines payable when targets are consistently unmet.
(The proceeds ought to be placed in a restitution fund against which patients can make a claim where they are able to demonstrate adverse medical outcomes as a result of delayed treatment.)
Until avoidable deaths are punished, avoidable deaths will continue. Until ministerial secrecy and inaction are punished, we will continue to get our fill of both. Scotland under devolution is a model of unaccountable government, with ministers rendered a law unto themselves by a pygmy parliament and subservient civil service.
But patients and their families cannot wait for Westminster to pluck up the interest – or courage – to do something about the fiasco that is Holyrood. They need meaningful change now. The opposition parties ought to make this a priority. Introduce legislation to enhance patient safety, with proper sanctions for those responsible for avoidable clinical deaths and those who withhold information about them from the public.
Of course the SNP and the Greens will vote it down. Let them. Let them be on record opposing safer hospitals and justice for patients. Let them explain that one to the voters. Patients are already vulnerable when they go in for surgery. They don’t need the additional worry of dying needlessly on the operating table.
Those responsible for such deaths are the ones who ought to worry.