At school, mathematics was the subject that most defeated me. I always sat next to my best mate Dave until I was moved down two sets.
Odd, really, considering I have now spent more than 40 years calculating measurements, estimating materials and building houses. If my maths had been as bad as the exam records show, none would be standing.
I may have struggled with classroom equations, but I also know when the figures, in the wider sense, do not add up. And right now, Britain’s figures make very little sense.
We are desperately short of homes. The construction industry needs thousands more skilled workers like me. Yet close to a million young people are Neets – not in education, employment or training. Surely we should be capable of putting those facts together?
I thought of my own ‘pathway into employment’ – do they just mean ‘going to work’? – when I read this week’s report by ex-Labour minister Alan Milburn, with its proposals for more apprenticeships, work experience and better links between education and employment.
My industry gets a specific mention, with proposals about linking construction training with employers’ needs in Liverpool. All sensible enough. But how did we get to a point where such obvious connections have to be rediscovered?
And how did we stray so far from the Britain where there was a clear path for a boy like me – not overly academic, but good in other ways – to get on. Mine wasn’t an easy path, but it was there.
Born in East London, at eight my family, along with Dave’s and thousands of others, moved to a sprawling council estate where the capital borders Essex. I grew up with simple advice: ‘Get a trade, boy. You’ll never be out of work.’

Author Andy Collier, a lifelong bricklayer, is pictured on the building site in his apprentice days
Andy Burnham was this week accused of selling out jobless British youngsters to push through his Brexit reset
I wasn’t a troublesome child, but lessons rarely held my attention. I loved art, woodwork, metalwork and technical drawing. I wanted to make things, not spend my days proving I could pass an exam. I got a thrill – still do – out of being faced with a pile of materials and creating something from them.
At 15, I discovered that three friends were being allowed out of school one day a week to attend college. One was learning mechanics, one carpentry and my mate Terry was trying bricklaying. I wanted to join him.
My teacher initially resisted. But my head of year, Mr Gainey, listened when I pointed out that I would be leaving school the following year without much idea of what to do. He let me go. It was one of the most important decisions anybody ever made for me.
At college, I was no longer the boy struggling in maths. I came out the best bloody bricklayer they’d had. The tutors treated us as young adults, and I worked hard because I could see where the lessons led.
That head start helped me secure a three-year apprenticeship with Tower Hamlets council. I was told there were thousands of applicants for only a handful of places. I went on to work for myself for 37 years, employing and training scores of other people and building houses the only way that works – from the ground up.
Dave went on to university. He now edits this newspaper. I was already earning good money when he was getting his degree and always gave him work in his term breaks. Neither of us had taken the wrong path. We had simply found different ones.
Margaret Thatcher was Prime Minister when I started. I remember the 1980s as years when a determined tradesman could make a good living. Her language of enterprise, independence and home ownership meant something to me. I wanted to stand on my own feet, and I did.
Yet there was another side to that decade. Factories closed, old industries contracted and the traditional training system began to unravel. Across Britain, the number of apprentices in employment roughly halved between 1979 and 1995. The decline had begun earlier, but by the time politicians appreciated what was disappearing, an established bridge from school to work was badly weakened.
John Major’s government introduced Modern Apprenticeships in the 1990s, an attempt to build new routes into skilled employment.
Then Tony Blair arrived with his own idea of opportunity: a university education should be within reach of far more young people.
His ambition for 50 per cent participation in higher education was intended to open doors once closed to working-class families. A worthwhile aim, but I believe this is where the rot really set in. Now I wonder whether the country absorbed a dangerous message: that an academic qualification was the gold standard of ambition, and that those of us who wanted to build things were settling for less.
Successive governments have had plenty of time to put that right, too. We have changed qualifications, funding and apprenticeship schemes repeatedly. What seems harder to restore is the simple connection I enjoyed between a school, a college and an employer.
Meanwhile, the building sites themselves changed. After the European Union expanded in 2004, many workers arrived from Poland and Lithuania. I’ve worked beside excellent Eastern European tradesmen; I don’t begrudge anyone the chance to earn a living. But in my experience the competition for jobs became fierce.
I remember day rates on some sites falling from about £180 or £200 to roughly £90. Construction wages depend on much more than immigration: the housing market, subcontracting, costs. Still, I question whether it became easier for firms to recruit foreign workers than to invest the time and money in training British youngsters.
Now we are in crisis, living with the consequences of a problem that has been growing for decades. The Construction Industry Training Board estimates that the sector needs about 206,000 additional workers over the four years to 2030. Those kids who could build the houses that will house their own families? Where are they?
And here is the part that makes me uncomfortable. Despite everything the trade has given me, I tried to talk my own sons out of becoming builders. I am 60. My knees, neck, back and hands have taken a battering. I have worked through freezing winters and long weekends. I have earned good money at times, but I have little pension provision, and after decades of self-employment, I now work for somebody else.
I would have liked my boys to have paid holidays, a pension, more certainty.
My eldest son Bradley went into building anyway. He enjoys creating things. I watch his eyes when he tells me that someone said ‘that’s beautiful, Brad’. It makes me happy and sad at the same time. And I still see young apprentices on sites who are keen and capable. So I won’t write off a whole generation as lazy.
Milburn is right to put first chances back on the agenda. Let young people see real workplaces before they leave school. Put them in an environment where they get to use maths without realising they are using maths. Give the practical child a chance to discover an ability that a classroom has overlooked.
And give small employers a reason to teach them, rather than expecting ready-made experience.
I truly believe every child has a talent, but the tragedy is that some will live their whole lives never discovering what it is. We’ve spent years teaching them how to pass exams, but we’ve forgotten to teach them how to work and valuing them for that work.
Apprenticeships alone won’t solve this. We must make skilled work worth pursuing for a lifetime, not just easier to enter at 16.
Mr Gainey saw something in me that an exam paper didn’t. Because of him, I helped build the homes other people live in.
Politicians talk endlessly about building a better future. Before promising another one, they should ask who, exactly, is going to be trusted with the bricks?