
Image source: Getty Images
Lloyds‘ (LSE:LLOY) share price has been on an incredible run of late, more than doubling over the last three years. In fact, anyone who put £5,000 into the bank in November 2023 and reinvested all the dividends paid along the way is now sitting on roughly £13,157.
That’s even after the stock slid around 16% from August’s 18-year high in the run-up to the Autumn Budget. So for those a bit late to the party, how much could £5,000 turn into over the next 12 months?
Exploring the latest Lloyds’ forecasts
Interestingly, despite the strong performance from this bank, several brokers have actually been trimming their price targets since October.
| Institutional Analyst | Old Target | New Target | Potential Gain |
| Barclays | 130p | 125p | 26.8% |
| Citi | 124p | 121p | 22.7% |
| Berenberg | 121p | 117p | 18.7% |
Compared to where Lloyds’ shares are trading today, the reduced forecasts still point to some solid potential gains on the horizon. And with dividends expected to hit 4.71p per share this year, a £5,000 investment now could grow to between £6,170 and £6,580 by this time next year.
But this raises the obvious question: if the bank is doing well, why’ve the targets been cut?
Digging deeper
Starting with the bull case, Lloyds is getting much better at turning a profit. Over the first nine months of 2026, income rose 9% while running costs crept up just 1%. As a result, the bank now spends around 49p to earn each £1 of income, down from 53p a year ago. And it’s how management was able to deliver an earnings beat for its third-quarter profits.
What’s more, mortgages, while still significant, are becoming a slightly smaller part of the mix in the bank’s loan book. Lending to businesses has jumped by £9.2bn this year, with loans to larger corporate clients up 14% despite the still elevated state of interest rates. And shareholders are already seeing the benefits.
Fun fact: with a fatter bottom line, the bank’s already completed a £1.75bn share buyback this year with another £1bn scheme under way.
So why the cuts?
Like most banks, Lloyds earns most of its money from the gap between what it pays savers and what it charges borrowers.
For the last few years, that gap’s been widening on the back of higher interest rates. But it’s also created a powerful tailwind for alternative digital banks and fintech platforms to offer more attractive terms for savers, creating a fiercer competitive landscape.
Subsequently, Lloyds is now starting to feel a bit of a pinch, with its net interest margin squeezed by digital rivals luring away deposits. Overall, margins are still rising, but management now expects net interest income to land only “modestly above” its £14.9bn target, whereas analysts had pencilled in a little over £15bn.
That’s why Berenberg thinks earnings forecasts for the next few years might have been a bit too optimistic. And the Autumn Budget didn’t help either, with the surcharge on bank profits jumping from 3% to 6%, taking a bite out of future earnings.
Even so, I think the bigger picture remains encouraging. I doubt Lloyds’ share price will repeat its explosive performance of the last three years. But for investors confident that Lloyds will overcome tougher competition, the bank stock could be worth a closer look.
What income stock do we like better than Lloyds Banking Group Plc right now?
One of our Share Advisor analysts has just released a brand new stock report that we think is a must-read for any investor looking to try and generate potential income.
And the best bit is that you can see if for yourself, right now, absolutely free of charge!
No jargon. No hard sell. Just a clear look at an income share we think is worth your time.
Zaven Boyrazian does not hold any positions in the companies mentioned.