A Wisconsin husband who allegedly claimed his wife suffered a fatal accident while doing laundry two years ago has been arrested for her murder after investigators uncovered a string of disturbing internet searches, deleted messages and evidence of a secret affair.
Benjamin Carpenter, 45, was taken into custody on Tuesday and charged with first-degree intentional homicide over the death of his wife, Erica Carpenter, 40, whose body was discovered at the couple’s home in West Allis, Wisconsin, on October 13 2024.
Erica’s parents, Debra and Michael Clarenbach, say the past two years have been filled with grief and unanswered questions.
They were beginning to heal from losing their only child when news of the criminal charges brought those emotions back. ‘Erica was one of a kind,’ said Debra.
More than two years after saying goodbye, her family says they are enduring another heavy blow.
‘It was like the wounds were starting to heal, and they ripped the bandage off again,’ Michael Clarenbach said.
For months, Carpenter allegedly maintained that his wife had died following a horrific accident on the stairs.
But a painstaking two-year investigation would uncover a far more troubling picture of the couple’s marriage – including allegations of infidelity, a potentially suspicious substance in Erica’s drinking water and Google searches made just hours before her death.

Benjamin Carpenter, 45, was taken into custody on Tuesday and charged with first-degree intentional homicide in connection with the death of his wife, 40-year-old Erica Carpenter
Police were called to a West Allis home for a welfare check for Erica Carpenter. Prosecutors said police arrived and found the 40-year-old woman bleeding from her head and blue in the face while her husband, Benjamin Carpenter, was performing CPR on her
Prosecutors said he told police his wife had not been feeling well and collapsed while they were in the basement of their home doing laundry. He said he tried carrying her up the stairs, and they fell together when she hit her head
According to a criminal complaint, officers were called to the family home on the night of October 13, 2024, after receiving reports that a woman had fallen and was bleeding from the head.
When responders arrived at the scene, they found Carpenter performing CPR on his wife, whose face was already described as ‘very blue’.
He told police Erica had been feeling unwell throughout the day and had spent much of it taking naps.
The couple had supposedly been doing laundry together when she suddenly collapsed, he claimed.
Carpenter allegedly told investigators the fall was so loud it woke their son, who was sleeping upstairs.
He initially described Erica hitting her head ‘mildly hard’ on the carpeted floor, yet rather than immediately calling emergency services, Carpenter allegedly attempted to carry his unconscious wife upstairs.
He then claimed he slipped on the staircase, causing both of them to tumble down the steps, with Erica striking her head against a cinder block wall.
Erica was rushed to hospital but was pronounced dead at 5.14am on October 14.
Through the course of the lengthy investigation, police said they discovered Carpenter had been having an affair with another woman and said he planned to tell his wife, but she died before that happened
Police said deleted text messages revealed his wife had questioned him about putting powder in her drinks.
When detectives questioned Carpenter about the state of their marriage, he reportedly replied: ‘It’s (short pause) good.’
He agreed to let investigators search all three of his mobile phones and provided the passcodes.
Asked whether he had deleted anything from the devices in the previous 24 hours, he allegedly insisted he had not.
However, the contents of those phones would later become central to the investigation.
Police began examining Carpenter’s personal life after a witness came forward on October 22, claiming a woman identified as AMV had been having an affair with him.
The woman reportedly believed Carpenter was preparing to divorce Erica and had allegedly been promised that he would ask his wife for a divorce the very weekend she died.
Investigators were also told Carpenter had spent the night at AMV’s home just days after Erica’s death and had discussed introducing her to his son.
At a pub-crawl fundraiser held in Erica’s memory around a month later, surveillance footage allegedly showed Carpenter and AMV behaving like a couple.

Police said that after news of Erica Carpenter’s death reached the couple’s social circles, an individual approached authorities on October 22, 2024. The witness informed them that a woman, identified with the initials ‘AMV,’ said she had been having an affair with Benjamin Carpenter and believed that he was in the process of divorcing his wife
Another witness, who had known Carpenter since high school and trained in mixed martial arts with him, told police he had admitted to the affair.
The witness said Carpenter claimed he had been preparing to divorce Erica after she discovered the relationship.
The investigation took another significant turn when detectives discovered Carpenter had received between $220,000 and $230,000 from Erica’s life insurance policy.
Although a separate joint policy worth $350,000 had not yet been paid out, according to the complaint.
During a December 2024 interview, Carpenter allegedly admitted the affair but claimed AMV had refused to date him until he was divorced.
Most shocking of all, in September 2024, less than a month before Erica’s death, Carpenter had allegedly searched Google for ‘Watching someone you love die’.
On October 13, the very day his wife died, he reportedly searched: ‘can I crush pills and take them in water’.
A further search on November 6 led investigators to a Facebook image bearing the words: ‘The hardest thing in the world is watching someone you love slowly die right in front of you.’
AMV reportedly told the witness that Benjamin Carpenter had promised to ask Erica Carpenter for a divorce the same weekend she died
Police also discovered deleted text messages, contradicting Carpenter’s earlier claim that he had not removed anything from his phones.
Perhaps most disturbing were messages allegedly exchanged between the couple weeks before Erica’s death.
On September 18, Erica reportedly confronted her husband about something unusual in her drinking water.
‘And what the f*** have you been doing to my water the past few days?!?!?’ she allegedly texted.
She followed up by saying there had been ‘powdery s***’ in it at least twice.
Carpenter reportedly replied that he had been putting Liquid I.V. in the water for himself and told her it was his drink.
An autopsy added further questions; Erica was found to have hydrocodone in her system, despite having no prescription for the medication. Investigators said its presence could not be ruled out as a possible contributor to her death.
Her cause of death was ultimately listed as undetermined. However, the medical examiner identified blunt-force injuries to her neck and petechial hemorrhaging – findings that can be associated with asphyxia.
Toxicology reports showed insomnia medication and hydrocodone in her system at the time of her death. Her final cause of death was undetermined, but the deputy chief medical examiner said her death may have been the result of asphyxia and indicated a blunt force neck injury
When the medical examiner questioned Carpenter about how he had been holding Erica during their alleged fall down the stairs, his explanation reportedly failed to account for why her heart had stopped beating.
In another disturbing development, police were called to the same home in May 2025 after AMV accused Carpenter of putting his hand around her neck and strangling her.
She allegedly told the Uber driver collecting her that if she died, Carpenter was responsible, before showing the driver his contact details on her phone.
In October 2025, investigators also interviewed the couple’s son. He reportedly recalled hearing a scream followed by a loud ‘thud’ on the night his mother died.
He also told police his father removed photographs of Erica from the family home around four weeks after her death. AMV subsequently moved into the property two or three months later.
Carpenter is now being held without bond at Milwaukee County Jail. He was scheduled to make his initial court appearance on Wednesday.
Michael Clarenbach said the investigation’s revelations have changed how the family views the man they once knew.
‘Completely blindsided,’ he said. ‘That it seemed like Ben had a dark side that we didn’t know about.’
The Daily Mail has reached out to Michael and Debra for comment.