A frontrunner has fallen out of the competition on Dancing With the Stars.

Jenna Dewan‘s Nov. 10 performance with pro Val Chmerkovskiy became her last on the show—despite receiving the second-highest scores from the judges on Grammy Night. 

For the evening featuring winning hits from music’s biggest night, the duo teamed up for a Jazz routine to Janet Jackson’s “All for You,” earning 28 out of 30 points. They also won their dance battle against Tatyana Ali and pro Jan Ravnik, which earned Dewan an extra two points.

After revealing the eliminated pair who will not move on to the Nov. 17 semi-finals, cohost Julianne Hough was nearly speechless, saying, “You’ve made it this far—it’s shocking, to say the least.”

But even after a controversial season—including a weeklong suspension for Chmerkovskiy over comments to judge Carrie Ann Inaba—Dewan shared how she is taking away positive memories.

“Dancing again, getting to share my joy with my family, who’s over here every single night—thank you, my baby—I had a great time,” she said, referring to fiancé Steve Kazee. “And I loved getting to share that with the world. Honestly, all love.”