With Super Bowl Night behind them, Shum Jr. and Johnson are more focused on celebrating their perfect score for their spooky routine, especially with legendary dancer Shirley Ballas guest-judging.

“We don’t do this show for validation, but that was the best validation of having someone like her to get the feedback and talk about kind of what she loved about it,” the Glee alum, still donning his blood-soaked clothes, told E!. “But we weren’t expecting it.”

“I know how much it means to you,” he said to Johnson, “also for me, as someone who came late to the game, like watching Shirley on Next Pro, and then going back and watching her videos, I’m like, ‘Oh my god!'”

While fans wait to see which celebs get even closer to the Mirrorball Trophy, keep reading to see all the stars who’ve laced up their dancing shoes this season.