Megan Walerius & Jordan Keltner: Split

Though the couple bonded over having loved ones with Type 1 diabetes, their differing lifestyles (he preferred a more simplistic way of life; she loves luxury) were a breaking point for Megan, who called off the wedding at the end of the season nine finale.

“We’re ships in the night, like two different people,” the entrepreneur told him. But the metaphor passed him by, with Jordan insisting, “I don’t see it.”

When Megan cited his picky eating habits and his inflexible travel schedule as a dad, Jordan told her, “I don’t know why you chose me in the pods then.” 

“Initially I leaned into opposites attract but I still just have reservations,” she explained before they each began crying. “Knowing this today, there’s no way I wanted to go to the altar and put either of us through that.”

Jordan shared his one regret was introducing her to his son, Luca, saying in a confessional, “I feel like she doesn’t love me for me and that’s the closure I need.”

Megan admitted the ordeal had her “questioning if I’m even cut out to be a mom. Maybe I am too caught up in my own life.”

But at the October 2025 reunion, she revealed she and partner Paul Wegman had welcomed a son they named Brooks.