Credit: Courtesy of Kyle Cooke/Instagram

The Fight Heard Throughout the Hamptons

During a May 2026 episode of Summer House, which filmed in August 2025, Carl and Kyle nearly came to blows after Carl tried to “calm down” Kyle following an outburst at the group table. (Kyle also told Amanda, “F*** you,” when she allegedly smirked at him, which caused the entire house to back her.)

“You bitched and whined all summer,” Kyle claimed, to which Carl responded, “What the f*** did I do to you except support your f***ing ass? I’ve been here for you all f***ing summer.”

As things escalated, Carl yelled, “Kyle, I will beat the f*** out of you.” Kyle, however, didn’t back down, screaming, “Carl, stop being a Vagasil!”

Kyle claimed that Carl had been talking behind his back all summer, alleging that everyone made him out to be the “bad guy” every time. “I’m sorry I forgot that Carl is 6 foot 5 and more fragile than a f***ing china doll,” Kyle quipped.

After Kyle cooled down, he apologized to Carl and told him he was triggered because their friend Ciara had recently revealed that she’d been talking with Amanda about possibly separating from him amid their marriage woes.

“Dude, I love you man. I’m sorry. I hate not being able to support you and not being able to help and I totally lost my s***,” Carl told Kyle, who cried as they embraced.

Kyle replied, “I’m sorry. That was heated,” he then admitted, “But I almost feel like you needed to get it out.”

Carl noted that he wasn’t upset about Kyle not being able to invest in Softbar, he just didn’t like how Kyle came after Amanda. “I think she f***ing can’t stand me,” Kyle confessed. “That makes me sad for you,” Carl confessed.